When you’ve gotta go…

I wasn’t planning on writing this today. I was planning on writing something about packaging design. But that’s been bumped to tomorrow, because last night my good friend Marianne wrote this post on her blog about public restrooms. And though I am sure I’d have gotten to writing about this topic *eventually*, suddenly it popped to the top of my schedule.

Now, I am not here to discuss this issue from the angle of body politics. This isn’t a blog *about* body politics. I’ve guest blogged over at The Rotund (Marianne’s site) before, talking about one of my biggest peeves in the entire design world- when the tables are too close together in restaurants (really, this drives me utterly batshit.) and how that affects body politics in three dimensional space. But since my blog is coming at this from a different angle, this post will too.

Ok, first of all, I want to address this, since it was written (probably largely in jest, but I have heard other, similar things said in all seriousness) in comments over there- there is no conspiracy as to why public bathrooms suck. It’s not a matter of gender politics. It’s not a matter of men designing things and not understanding the needs of women. It’s not a tinfoil hat scenario. The reason why public bathrooms suck (and in this context, I’m using public to mean “any space not in a private residence”, not truly public space) can be summed up in ONE word:

Money.

Folks, no one ever made any real money out of people needing a place to pee unless we’re talking about a pay toilet. The truth is that the rest rooms in almost all of the public spaces you encounter are designed with very few considerations:

  • using the least amount of floor space possible, in order to save square footage for money generating activities.
  • using the least amount of money possible, in order to save design and construction funds for things that will generate income on the far end.
  • fulfilling the legal requirements in terms of building code (and in the US, the ADA) *and that’s it.* (why? see the two points above this.)

The rest room setups that most of us are familiar with are *standardized* and because they are standardized they are *CHEAP* to produce. They are designed to use the least amount of space *legally allowable* in order to leave more room for the things that are needed to generate revenue. That’s IT. Period. There’s nothing more to “read into it.” I promise.

That being said, I have been waging (what often feels like single-handed) war on the standardized design of restrooms since I started my design career. Because I think they SUCK, and we can do much better. It genuinely bothers me that in a space like the Time-Warner Center at Columbus Circle here in NYC, designed by SOM, who by any accounting you could consider have both more money and talent than any firm needs to know what to do with STILL HAS LOUSY BATHROOMS(though I have to thank them for providing a convenient and free place to pee on the west side. Thanks, guys!). The space is so carefully crafted- so thoughtfully planned out… and then you walk down this long corridor towards the rest rooms and it suddenly feels like an afterthought. Plain white walls, standardized stalls.. you name a cliché here and it’s there. And there’s no *reason* for it. Because if what you’re selling, ultimately, is an *experience* (and boy howdy that’s what retail is selling you, as well as product and don’t you forget it), as much as people are grateful (really! I’m grateful) for a free place to pee on the west side, the illusion you’re creating is BLOWN when the bathrooms suck.

I love to design restaurants, retail spaces, hospitality, nightclubs, bars… all those kinds of places that you find the kind of bathrooms we’re talking about here. And I know for sure that *it can be done*. It’s BEEN done. It’s been done at Bar89. It’s been done in the (now gone.. *snif*) lobby of The Royalton, in the men’s room(don’t ask me how I know that). It’s been done (and still my favorite in all of NYC) at Peep. I know it’s been done all over my damned portfolio. It’s been done in a whole lot of places, actually, all over the world. So it *is* doable. The question is for designers, why aren’t we fighting to do it more often? It’s a fantastic design opportunity and if you do it well it becomes a serious talking point and something people will go to see. Why is the design of a restroom so often an afterthought (and it looks it- you aren’t fooling anyone, you know.)

And if you question whether or not people *WANT* that; whether or not they want changes in how rest rooms are designed, even if it means paying a buck or two extra for their meal or whatever, go read the comments over at the post I linked to at the start of this. Work from there.

Advertisements

6 Comments

  1. There are retail spaces I go to less frequently because their bathrooms suck so very much. I don’t like spending my money at a place where I can pee with some modicum of dignity, you know?

    The standardization of stalls and their fixtures would bother me less if there seemed to be some thought to the placement of the fixtures. It’s okay if the feminine products trash can thingie is on the same level as the toilet paper dispenser as long as they aren’t at knee level, you know? But UGH.

    And I have to say, I really want to see the bathroom of QQQQ.

  2. I’m working on providing an image of the bathrooms at QQQQ. We’re still working on a dining room perspective (QQQQ was one of the projects that had to be rebuilt, so it’s been taking a while.) It’s supposed to happen after this one is finished, though. The design at Black Tied was nice too, but I didn’t have to call it out(despite the weeks of work on it).

  3. I assume hotel room baths are (while standardized) better designed because it’s considered part of the selling features of a room, especially in the “not Motel 6” category? Do hotels with good guest room bathroom design typically still have crappy general area restroom design?

    I second the QQQQ request. Where are the sinks in that restroom, anyway?

  4. Hotel rooms themselves have much more latitude than say, a hotel lobby. The rooms themselves (hi, see my jail bathroom for TFC?) are much more flexible. Kind of the best mix you can get of contract/residential. But spaces where you have more than one person using the facilities at the same time tend to lose creativity quickly.

    Oh, and the sink is that long thing in the middle.

  5. One of my biggest (of many) pet peeves about public restrooms are doors that open into the bathroom (or doors that open out, but have knobs or levers). This is especially true in restaurants. After I have washed my hands in preparation for eating my meal, I do not want to have to touch the door with my hands in order to escape the restroom. Being able to simply press it open with my elbow or shoulder is so much better. Failing that, a garbage can right near the door so that I can open it with a paper towel and then throw that away (assuming they have paper towels).

    I could go on for ages complaining about public bathrooms.

  6. This complaint is often a product of a combination of space and occupancy. In general, unless one is required by law to have a door open outward into the corridor(like you would in a space that has over 75 people in it), in order to maintain safety (no one getting smacked in the face with a door) and to save space that could be allotted to something else, the door tends to swing inward into the room as a rule. This is, btw why many large bathroom installations don’t have doors at all- it is sometimes easier to do that than try to mess around with a door swing.


Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s